Is Costco’s Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream worth buying? Unfortunately, my experience with this product was disappointing, especially when compared to other premium brands like Haagen-Dazs.

While the price of Kirkland’s vanilla ice cream might be tempting, the quality falls short compared to its competitors. The texture was icy rather than the creamy smoothness you’d expect from a “super premium” product.

Additionally, the vanilla flavor lacked the richness and depth found in other brands. Given the choice, I would rather buy Haagen-Dazs or even other mid-range options, which provide a more satisfying flavor and texture.

Other Products From Costco are Clovis Farms Organic Super Smoothie, Costco Ham And Cheese Pastry Review, Catalina Crunch Keto Friendly Cereal, Kirkland Organic Spinach & Cheese Ravioli, Famous Dave’s Original Recipe Corn Bread Mix and the  Maven’s Durian Ice Cream

Costco Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream Review

Taste Test

I found the Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream to be bland and lacking in sweetness. The vanilla flavor was not super intense; in fact, I would describe it as barely there.

Additionally, the ice cream had a milky aftertaste, similar to the taste left in your mouth after drinking whole milk.

It felt like a step above completely unflavored ice cream, and I would suggest that it would not work well in a milkshake due to its lack of sweetness.

Nutrition Analysis

Looking at the nutrition facts for Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream, it’s obvious that this treat is high in calories and fat. The container has 24 servings, with each serving size being 2/3 cup (144g). Here’s a breakdown of what you get per serving:

• Calories: 360
• Total Fat: 23g

From a nutritional perspective, this ice cream is quite rich and should be enjoyed as an occasional treat rather than a regular snack. Its high calorie count, driven by its significant fat content, means it’s packed with energy — great for indulgence but not ideal for those monitoring their caloric intake.

The saturated fat content is 13g per serving, which is over half of the recommended daily limit for most adults.

Cholesterol levels are also high at 150mg per serving.The sodium content is moderate at 75mg, but it can add up with other daily sodium intake.

Additionally, the ice cream contains 25g of added sugars per serving, making it a high-sugar item.

The 6g of protein per serving is a positive, the high levels of fat, saturated fat, cholesterol, and added sugars mean that Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream should be consumed sparingly and with consideration of one’s overall dietary goals.

Ingredients Analysis

The ingredients list of Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream includes Fresh Cream, Skim Milk, Sugar, Pasteurized Egg Yolks, Vanilla Extract, Carob Bean Gum, and Guar Gum. It also contains Milk and Eggs.

Sugar is used for sweetness, but the ice cream seemed to lack effective sweetness, possibly due to an imbalance or insufficient quantity.

The use of natural Vanilla Extract is a good choice for a pure and rich vanilla flavor, though this was not evident in the taste test.

Carob Bean Gum and Guar Gum are natural thickeners and stabilizers that enhance texture and consistency, ensuring the ice cream maintains its structure and creaminess during storage and serving.

While these ingredients are high quality, Kirkland’s product did not meet expectations. For those who prefer natural ingredients and fewer additives, the list might seem satisfactory.

Despite the potential of these ingredients, the end result in this ice cream does not live up to the “super premium” label.

CONTAINS: Milk and Eggs. Be mindful of these allergens if you have sensitivities or allergies.

Convenience

I noted that the ice cream comes in a large package of two half-gallon cartons, which I found to be a big commitment and inconvenient compared to buying a single half-gallon at Sam’s Club.

Having to purchase two cartons at once might be too much ice cream for some people, especially for those who prefer to enjoy different flavors more frequently.

The size and weight of the packaging also add to the inconvenience, making it cumbersome to handle and store, particularly in smaller freezers. This bulk packaging might not suit every household, especially those with limited freezer space or who are looking for more variety in their ice cream selection.

Price Analysis

The Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream costs $15.99 for two half-gallon cartons, totaling 64 fluid ounces. I did not feel the price justified the quality of the product. Considering the icy texture and lackluster vanilla flavor, the cost seems steep compared to other premium brands that offer superior taste and creaminess.

While the bulk packaging may appear to offer good value on the surface, the disappointing quality undermines any savings. For the same price or slightly more, you can purchase brands that deliver a far more gratifying ice cream experience.

Reddit Users Review

Product reviews for Kirkland ice cream from Reddit users are generally positive, with a few concerns:

• One user compares the ice cream to Kirkland Signature 4-piece golf balls, indicating it offers great value for its price.
• Another user suggests it’s a better value than Blue Bell ice cream but is unsure if it tastes better.
• The packaging is criticized by a user who questions the necessity of the box for 2 containers. They also note that despite being more expensive than Trader Joe’s super premium ice cream, it doesn’t match up in taste.
• High demand is implied by a user curious if the product is available in Canada.
• The taste is praised by another user who enjoys the solid vanilla flavor, which pairs well with bakery apple pie.
• A comparison with Haagen Dazs ice cream is made by a user who prefers Haagen Dazs due to its lack of added stabilizers, which gives Kirkland a slightly gummy texture.

Review Score

• Taste : 6/10
• Nutrtion: 5/10
• Ingredients: 7/10
• Convenience: 7/10
• Price : 6/10

Overall

Give it a Try!

While Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream promises high quality through its ingredient list and marketing, my experience suggests it doesn’t quite meet the “super premium” label. Its rich nutritional profile, with significant calories and high fat content, means it should be enjoyed in moderation.

Despite using natural ingredients, the ice cream lacks the expected creamy texture and robust vanilla flavor. The large bulk packaging can be inconvenient for some, and at $15.99, the price doesn’t match the quality compared to other premium brands.

However, it has its fans on Reddit who appreciate its value and compatibility with other desserts. So, while it may not be the best choice for everyone, it could be worth trying if you want a large quantity of vanilla ice cream at a moderate price.

FAQs

---

Disclaimer

Please be aware that this review is independent and unbiased. The product was purchased by Costcoverdict solely for the purpose of creating this review. The opinions expressed here belong solely to Costcoverdict and do not reflect any affiliation with Costco or its suppliers. Should Costcoverdict ever receive compensation from a product manufacturer or any other third party, full disclosure will be provided, including instances where a product sample was provided for review purposes