Costco Kirkland Pecan Pie Review: Is It Worth the Hype? 2024

Looking to uncover the truth about the renowned Costco Kirkland Signature Pecan Pie? Take a deep dive into this in-depth review to discover whether this decadent, sweet, buttery, and nutty dessert priced at $16.99 lives up to its widespread acclaim! Immerse yourself in the intricate layers of the golden, flaky crust, the luscious pecan filling, and the harmonious blend of flavors that have made this dessert a beloved choice for many. Delve further into the sumptuous texture, irresistible aroma, and overall luxurious experience of indulging in this delightful treat that promises a taste sensation and a truly memorable culinary journey.

Costco Kirkland Pecan Pie Review

Flavor Profile for Costco Pecan Pie

Costco’s Kirkland Pecan Pie boasts a delightful mix of sweet, savory, and nutty flavors.

Sweetness: The pie’s sweetness comes from its thick, sugary custard filling. Some might find it overly sweet, but it’s a hit for those with a sweet tooth.
Savory: The crust adds a savory touch, balancing the sugary filling.
Nutty: Pecans on top provide a deep nutty flavor that complements the custard, though some debate the pecan quality.
Buttery: The crust is not just savory but also buttery, adding richness and a flaky texture.
Richness: The heavy custard and buttery crust create a rich taste that some might find overwhelming but enjoyable for hearty dessert lovers. The Costco Kirkland Pecan Pie is a flavorful treat, though preferences vary widely.

Size and Price Assessment

Costco’s Kirkland Pecan Pie is famous for being a hefty 5-pound pie, perfect for big gatherings. Priced at $16.99, it offers excellent value for its size. While some debate its sweetness and pecan quality, its worth depends on personal taste and preference for convenience over artisanal quality.

Nutritional Analysis for Costco Pecan Pie

Costco’s Kirkland Pecan Pie is a decadent, calorie-packed dessert for 16 servings, each providing a hefty 540 calories. This pie is a lavish treat with a high-fat content, mainly from pecans and a buttery crust. Each slice boasts 29 grams of fat, about 33.8% of the pie. Carbs comprise 26.3%, totaling 66 grams per serving, mainly from sugar and the crust. Protein content is lower at 5 grams per serving, making up 12% of the pie. While delicious, this pie is best enjoyed in moderation due to its high calorie, fat, and sugar content. Considering these nutritional facts is essential if you’re mindful of your diet or health.

Ingredient Breakdown for Costco Pecan Pie

While the exact ingredient list for Costco’s Pecan Pie isn’t publicly disclosed, here are the key components you can expect:

Pecans: These nuts take the spotlight, adding richness with 29g of fat and 5g of protein per serving.
Sugar: With 540 calories per serving, sugar likely plays a significant role, a common feature in traditional pecan pies.
Eggs: Used for binding and texture, eggs are a staple in pecan pie recipes.
Butter: Reviews hint at a buttery taste, indicating its presence in the filling and crust for richness.
Flour: The crust is typically flour-based, contributing to the 66g of carbs per serving.
Corn Syrup: Common in modern recipes, corn syrup adds sweetness and a gooey texture.

This approximate breakdown is based on standard pecan pie ingredients and available nutritional info. Check the product’s ingredient list or consult Costco for specific details, especially if you have dietary restrictions or allergies.

Evaluation of Pecan Quality for Costco Pecan Pie

In the article “Consumer Attitudes and Consumption Patterns for Pecans and Other Tree Nuts: Beyond a Simple Shell Game,” it was noted that factors such as the grade, size, and quality of pecans can impact consumer attitudes. This might suggest that Costco, as a large retailer, would be interested in ensuring the quality of its pecans to maintain customer satisfaction.

Anecdotal evidence from a piece in “FALL PROGRAMS EXPLORE ICONS IN AMERICAN, ASIAN, AND ARGENTINE FOOD” suggests a focus on the quality and safety of ingredients in Kirkland’s products, which includes their Pecan Pie.

While these sources do not directly evaluate the quality of the pecans in Costco’s Pecan Pie, they provide some context around the importance of pecan quality and the potential considerations Costco might make when sourcing ingredients for its products.

Heating Instructions for Costco Pecan Pie

Costco’s Pecan Pie is usually sold entirely baked and ready to eat, so you don’t have to heat it before serving. If you prefer it warm, follow these simple steps:

Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C).
Let the pie sit at room temperature for 15-30 minutes after removing it from the fridge.
Heat the pie in the oven for 10-15 minutes until warm. Avoid overheating to prevent sugar from burning.

These are general heating tips for baked pies and may not be Costco-specific. Always check the packaging for any specific instructions from the manufacturer.

Refrigeration Guidelines for Costco Pecan Pie

It’s best to refrigerate your Costco Pecan Pie for safekeeping and to prolong its shelf life. Here are the main points to remember:

Refrigerate your Costco Pecan Pie within two hours.
The USDA advises keeping egg-rich pecan pies in the fridge for freshness, lasting around three to four days when chilled.
For more extended storage, freezing is an option. Store pecan pie properly in the refrigerator for three to four days or freeze it for extended storage.

Mashed also recommends refrigerating Costco’s pie, especially egg-rich varieties like pecan, pumpkin, lemon meringue, and custard. Remember to cool the pie before refrigerating or freezing to avoid condensation that can make the crust soggy.

Review Rating for Costco Pecan Pie

Taste (9/10): Costco’s Pecan Pie is delicious with its perfect mix of sweet filling and nutty pecans in a flaky crust, making it a popular choice.

Value (8/10): This pie offers excellent value for its quality and taste, providing a gourmet experience without costing too much.

Quality (9/10): The pie’s quality shines through every bite, showcasing Costco’s commitment to excellence.

Convenience (9/10): Easy to serve and perfect for gatherings, this pie is a hassle-free option for any occasion.

Cost (8/10): Priced at $16.99, it may seem expensive, but many find it worth the cost due to its size, taste, and quality.

Nutrition (5/10): While not the healthiest choice, this Pecan Pie is a delightful treat best enjoyed in moderation.

Overall Satisfaction (8/10): Costco’s Pecan Pie offers a satisfying dessert experience, blending taste, quality, value, and convenience. Despite its lower nutrition score, customers are generally highly pleased with this indulgence.

Concluding Remarks for Costco Pecan Pie

In conclusion, Costco’s Pecan Pie offers its customers a delicious and high-quality dessert option. While the exact sourcing of ingredients needs to be clarified, it can be assumed that Costco considers factors such as quality and safety when choosing suppliers for their products. The pie can be heated for those who prefer it warm. Still, proper storage guidelines should also be followed to ensure freshness and safety. Costco’s Pecan Pie provides an outstanding balance of taste, value, convenience, and quality, making it a top pick for any dessert lover. So, grab a Pecan Pie and indulge in this tasty treat next time you’re at Costco!

Video Review

Author’s Note

This pie review is independent and not affiliated with Costco. The views expressed are solely the author’s and do not represent Costco’s official stance. Scores and thoughts are based on the author’s experience with the product, offering a personal viewpoint. Every attempt has been made to provide an honest and unbiased review to assist consumers in making informed choices.

What is the size of Costco’s Pecan Pie?

Costco’s Pecan Pie is known for its generous size, typically serving around 12 people.

How much does Costco’s Pecan Pie cost?

As of the last update, Costco’s Pecan Pie retails for $16.99, but prices may vary by location and season.

Does Costco’s Pecan Pie contain any allergens?

The pie contains wheat, eggs, milk, and pecans, so it’s unsuitable for individuals with allergies to these ingredients.

How should I store my Costco Pecan Pie?

For maximum freshness, storing the pie in a cool, dry place or refrigerating it is recommended. If you want to keep it longer, you can freeze it.

Can I order Costco’s Pecan Pie online?

Availability may vary, but Costco’s bakery items, including the Pecan Pie, are generally available for in-store pickup.

Why is the nutritional score for Costco’s Pecan Pie lower?

As a dessert, the Pecan Pie has a high sugar content and is calorie-dense, contributing to its lower health score.

What are the ingredients in Costco’s Pecan Pie?

The main ingredients are pecans, corn syrup, eggs, sugar, butter, and a blend of enriched wheat flour for the crust. However, for the most accurate and up-to-date list of ingredients, it’s best to check the label on the pie itself.

Is Costco’s Pecan Pie available year-round?

Availability can vary by location and time of the year. The Pecan Pie is a seasonal item that is more readily available during the holiday season.